I have a huge daring problem D:?

So I like two different girls.... One, we will call her Beth, I was in the middle of setting up with my bestfriend when I figured out I liked her:/. She obviously likes him and would never like me. The second(Jess) is more y, but she has liked me in the past and I like her. Jess is currently OBSESSED with this guy that lives about forty minutes away. So who do I choose to pursue? Sweet and funny Beth? Or y and seductive Jess? Please help me :/